Saturday, April 6, 2024

Challenges and Opportunities in an Ageing Society Mahendra Gonsalkorale

Challenges and  Opportunities in an Ageing Society

Mahendra "Speedy" Gonsalkorale

I like to reproduce my Reunion Presentation in Sept 2012 as it is even more relevant now. There is a short update addendum at the end.

This is a summary of the Lecture delivered by Dr Mahendra Gonsalkorale at the 50th Anniversary Reunion Academic session of the Medical Entrants of 1962 in Sri Lanka on September 1, 2012.

The World population is growing rapidly. From an estimated 2.5 billion in 1950, it reached 6.1 billion in 2000 and is projected to grow to 8.2 billion in 2025. It took over 4000 years to reach 2 billion but it will take less than 75 years to quadruple that number. Sri Lanka’s current population of just over 20 million will grow to 23 million by 2030. People are also surviving longer at all ages and increasingly achieving old age. Increased life expectancy is a Global phenomenon. Correspondingly, due to the decrease in fertility rates, there is less than the expected numbers of younger people, and the net result is a change in the age distribution pyramid from the familiar broad-based, gradually tapering shape as in the mid 60s and before, to one with a relatively narrower base with a “fat” middle (the older people) and a taller shape (because of the persistence of the very old).
 

 

 The proportion of elderly people in all countries is increasing. From about 4-10% just 50 years ago to 15-20% now and expected to increase to 25-30% in the mid 2000s. In Sri lanka, there are about 1.9 million over the age of 60 (10%) and this is expected to increase to 4.5 million (25%) by 2040. There are currently around 40 million over 65s in America compared to 23M just 50 years ago. Within the over 60s, there is a massive increase in the very old. The balance between the older and younger is affected and this will significantly affect the care of older people and the financing of pensions.

1 More old people and less (proportionately) young people means

2 More age-associated diseases such as dementia (Alzheimer’s), cardiovascular diseases, degenerative neurological disorders, cancer, arthritis and related disorders, chronic respiratory disease, and other chronic diseases.

3 Increase in disability levels in the population

4 Less people to support and care for older people.

5 Large increases in health and social care costs. 

The burden of Dementia is one of the most worrying concerns for the future. The WHO estimates that worldwide, nearly 35.6 million people live with dementia. This is expected to double by 2030 (65.7 million) and more than triple by 2050 (115.4 million). The vast majority of these will be elderly.

Dementia affects people in all countries, with more than half (58%) living in low- and middle-income countries. By 2050, this is likely to rise to more than 70%. The WHO observes that only eight countries worldwide currently have national programmes in place to address dementia.  

This may all sound very negative, but there is a more optimistic view to be taken, and with greater preparation and anticipation of need, the lives of both the elderly and the young could be enhanced. Older people can have a better quality of life, and the young can look forward to a time of fulfilment and relative leisure when they become old. 

Some of the challenges that need to be met are the following. 

(1)  Meeting health, social and housing needs. These are also fuelled by rising expectations, technological advances which are often costly, medical breakthroughs and other factors

(2)  Resourcing  (financial and other)  the demands of an ageing population who consume more resources, with the added factor of a relative decrease  in economically productive young wage earners

(3)  Evolving a society devoid of intergenerational disputes and replete with respect and love - a cohesive, equitable and productive society, with the wisdom and maturity of old age, balancing the exuberance of youth. Today’s young are tomorrow’s old; all have a stake. 

These challenges could be met by adopting various measures such as, 

(1)  A major shift in attitudes and perceptions of what it means to progress through life from birth to death, getting rid of the negative image of old age, utilisation of a range of skills and talents of old people set free from the need to pursue active employment, greater involvement in voluntary work, providing support for children and grandchildren.  

(2) When the retirement age was set years ago, the expectation was that retired people would live on average about 5 years more before they die according to life expectations at the time. This has changed over the years and at present, retired people can expect to live at least a further 10 years or more. This has major funding implications and current pension arrangements are not sustainable and the concept of retirement needs to be reviewed. The Shakespearean concept of 3 score years and 10 is outmoded and a good model is one of the 3 ages, the first is one of growing up and learning, the second is one of adulthood with employment, marriage and parenthood and the third age is one of gradual withdrawal from active employment with pursuit of leisure. These are blend into each other. 

(3)  Forward planning to meet the demands of a large increase in the number of old people.  

(4)  Change emphasis from a Disease Model to a Preventive model. The aim is to ensure that longevity is matched by a long disability-free period and not by the nightmare scenario of prolonging life by extending the period of disabled life that often precedes death, using the old adage, “add life to years and not years to life”.

 (5)  Towards this end, the message is that living a healthy life when you are young has to be promoted to achieve a healthy old age.

Among the suggested measures are:- 

•  control of hypertension,

•  attention to a proper diet, weight control

•  regular mental and physical exercise

•   correction of lipid abnormalities

•   smoking cessation

•   correction of abnormalities of heart rhythm, such as atrial fibrillation

•  Social interventions, such as libraries, heating allowances, and free health checks, need funding but will produce long-term savings and benefits.

•  Imaginative housing and home care schemes

•  Incentives such as low-cost or free recreational facilities and transport for older people  

(6) Creative use of new technologies, e.g., telemedicine, smart homes, and house robots.  

(7) Suitable national and international legislation to protect older people. 

(8) It is also suggested that we need to rethink our attitude to death and prolongation of life. The largest proportion of the total healthcare budget spent per person is at the end of life.

Death is as inevitable as life and without death, life cannot be sustained. Death is not a failure; accept death with dignity and equanimity.  

In conclusion,  

We must change how we think about our lives and progress from birth to death.

We have to re-engineer the concept of retirement

We need to devote more resources towards dementia research

We need to fight against ageism and paternalism. We must escape from the concept of A World for the Young to a World for All.

We need to harness the immense potential of technology and remain optimistic.

Addendum on 6th April 2024

As ageing was regarded as a “natural” process, not much energy was devoted to its underlying mechanisms. In other words, nobody seriously considered altering the ageing process through manipulative processes.

With the outlook for longevity improving, curiosity about the ageing process itself was aroused. Why do animals age? What are the genetic and environmental causes? Is it possible to slow down or even abolish the ageing process? Will a change in the rate of ageing reduce age associated disease?

Studies into the ageing process have made big advances recently. The genetics of ageing, the role of stem cells, the role of inflammation, and changes in fat metabolism are just a few. We are yet to see implementable strategies to change the ageing process in Humans although there are some promising animal experiments.

Of those still alive in our batch, we are all over the age of 75. The time when many of the actions we could have (and should have taken) is sadly now gone. BUT…

It is never too late to institute lifestyle changes and take therapeutic measures if indicated.

Wishing to slow the ageing process is not mainly about living longer but about living healthier and happier for longer. (as shown in the famous Fries Compression of morbidity graph above)



17 comments:

  1. Mahen, thank you for getting this important discussion going. I remember your excellent presentation and at that time "old age" seemed a bit distant! But, by the end of 2024 all of us (batch mates) who are alive would have reached their 80th birthday. I hope that there will be significant participation in this discussion from those who regularly access the blog. As you say, we need to change our way of thinking. I'm very interested in the discussions that are going on about biological age and chronological age. I think we will learn more and more about that in the near future. We cannot stop the process of aging, but we can take steps to make the best of it. Older people can contribute a lot in multiple ways. Volunteering activities that are close to one's heart is a great way to interact with people who may be different and/or younger.
    I believe in being proactive and making decisions that will help us navigate advancing age. One of them is simplifying the way you live, which includes divesting yourself of unnecessary possessions. Change is tough, but it is easier when the person making the decision is you, and not someone else making the decisions for you.
    We don't have complete control of our health, but I believe exercise and social interactions are extremely important. Personally my attitude towards exercise, is like taking my medicine. I don't particularly like it, but I do it anyway, some form of exercise everyday. Of course, certain activities are fun and we need to continue doing them - regularly.
    The increasing prevalence of dementia and its causes raise a lot of questions in my mind. I don't accept the explanation that it is just because we are living longer. Is it because of environmental pollution? Is it because so many of a being prescribed medications with murky side effects. There a some links to certain statins. I would love to hear from someone who knows more about this.
    I don't just want to live long, I want to live well and hopefully have a positive impact on the people around me. When the time comes to say goodbye, I want to go with dignity - but that will be a topic for a separate comment!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Edit: The sentence should read: Is it because so many of us are being prescribed medications with murky side effects?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you, Mahen, for the treatise on the important issues of ageing, the many problems of living longer and exiting this world with dignity.
    When I see the figures and graphs I am reminded of the Faculty days and the statistics I learnt as a part of public health. It didn’t make any sense then and doesn’t do much better even now. But that is my problem and not a criticism of your fine elucidation and colourful presentation.
    There are many issues which are complex and little understood at the present time. I agree with Srianee, it is great to have a long life but it is the quality of life that is crucial. The many factors mentioned to keep clear of the dreaded dementia that has reached ‘pandemic’ proportions in the elderly worldwide are worthy of care and respect. There are many researchers looking for the magic bullet that can delay the onset or reverse the process of dementia. People young and old must begin to take this problem seriously and force their governments to invest and promote these researchers and pharmaceutical companies. This is indeed a real possibility of serious trouble ahead and they should work on it now and without delay.
    We all must and will die. Thinking more seriously about the way we exit this world is important too. Should people with terminal illness be allowed to ‘call it a day’ when the suffering is endless? I do hope criteria can be laid out for this after careful thought.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Mahendra
    Congratulations ! on your excellent article.
    We batchmates are all in our old age. So this article is useful to all of us.
    People are living longer with better health facilities and medication.
    Though we are doctors most of us have stopped practice.
    Not only should we take the medication for whatever we have Hypertension, Diabetes etc. but we should occupy ourselves with some activity Reading, playing Golf Badminton, exercise, painting Sewing etc. We should relax and let our brain work. We don't know what we are in for the future.
    Some of our batchmates are suffering from Alzeimer, Dymentia etc.
    As stated by you, 35 million are suffering from Dymentia world wide and it will be three times more in 2050. This is frightening !
    Can research help ?
    Is it possible to help our ageing population suffering Dymentia ?
    Or is it possible to prevent our ageing population getting Dymentia ?
    Can research help ?
    I totally agree with your phrase
    "Living a healthy life when you are young has to be promoted to achieve a healthy old age. "
    Chira

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks a lot Srianee, Nihal and Chira for your comments. You have all posed very relevant thoughts and I shall respond very soon. This is a very important topic. Our knowledge of the ageing process and our attitudes to old age are changing rapidly. There are a lot exciting new developments in research into ageing and also in Alzheimer's disease which are related. Dementia is a broad group of conditions causing cognitive deteriration and Alzheimer's is just one cause of it. If we crack Alzheimer's, it would revolutionise our concept of life as we get older.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Speedy thank you for your post on aging and the valuable advice.
    I do remember your talk at our reunion in 2012, so comprehensive and with a lot of food for thought It was great to be able to read it .. more than once !

    May I be permitted to make a correction... You had referred to three score years and ten as a Shakespearian view of the expected life span of a human... Actually it's from the Holy Bible. Book of Psalms Ch 90: Vs 10.

    As you very correctly point out we all need to aim to have good physical as well as mental health.It is alarming when our abilities in both spheres begin to deteriorate, and as you emphasize a positive attitude goes a long way....we need to accept the things you can change and what you cannot and have the wisdom to differentiate between them.

    We all tend to neglect mental exercise and I think this is definitely harmful. We need to spend quality time engaging in spiritual activities whether it is meditation, Bhavana, Bible Study or Prayer, whatever is relevant to each one of us.
    I feel our parents paid far more attention to this aspect, and they led far more tranquil lives than us.
    You may argue that life is more stressful today, but we also have more facilities for treating disease and a better understanding of total health

    I find doing Cross word puzzles, Sudoku , and Word puzzles, on a regular basis does help , and In my case helping th 6 grands with their home work is of great mutual benefit !

    Engaging in creative activities like Chira is obviously great, but not all of us are skilled in that way
    Do you think that the increased pollution in our world, use of Chemicals/ over medication has an effect on this problem?
    Once again thank you for bringing this topic for your discussion.
    Suri

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Suri, many thanks for your comment. You are of course absolutely correct about the origin of the quote which is from the Holy Bible. Book of Psalms Ch 90: Vs 10. I always associated it with Shakespeare and Macbeth. In Macbeth: where in Act 2, Scene 4, Ross, a messenger to Macbeth with bad news that he has been given the title Thane of Cawdor by Duncan, enters with an Old Man who says:-"Threescore and ten I can remember well:"
      Threescore and ten"—70 years—is the traditional number for a life-span ended by simple old age; if this man can "remember well" seventy years, he is probably even older.
      I echo your broad minded thoughts in recognising that we have a range of beliefs and must act accordingly. As you say, "We need to spend quality time engaging in spiritual activities whether it is meditation, Bhavana, Bible Study or Prayer, whatever is relevant to each one of us.".
      I really believe that it is not possible to comapre stress levels in society in different periods of time. This reminds me of the Renal colic sufferer saying to the Biiary colic sufferer that his pain is far worse, who is contradicted in turn by the woman who says ther pain is nothing like hers, who had a most difficult delivery!
      Increased pollution,climate change etc are real problems which are not being dealt with adequately because of our lack of intergenerational thinking. Short termism and instant rewards and self indulgence are far too common. Having said that, we must not generalise too much as there are a lot of wonderful people in this planet.
      Thanks again Suri. As the last person in our Batch who will be entering the 80 club in a few months time, you are doing really well!

      Delete
  7. Thank you very much Mahendra for your excellent article, which is becoming more significant and relevant with each passing day. Although I retired from the Colombo Medical Faculty on the 30th of September 2008, I am more busy now. From April 2008 until 2022, I worked as a Visiting Senior Professor at the Rajarata Medical Faculty. About 6 years ago the Vice-Chancellor of the Sabaragamuwa University, invited me to establish a Medical Faculty, which was opened by Ranil W. , when he was the Prime Minister ,at that time. Presently there are 6 batches of students and the first batch is doing their Professorial Appointments, right now.
    I am the current Chairman of the Board of Trustees of the Thalagolla Convalescent Home for Children, which was founded by Prof. C C de Silva in 1951.
    I am also the current Chaiman of the Meththa Rehabilitation Foundation which provides prosthetic limbs to amputees. My friend Dr. Panagamuwa founded it.
    Recently I was invited to be the Chief Consultant to establish Private Medical Schools by Lyceum and SLIIT. I was the President of CoMSAA last year. By all means, it is not a case of "all work and no play"; I regularly play a card game called Gin Rummy with a few friends during most evenings.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sanath, if I have to cite a living example of a person who has observed most of the practices that I have recommended, there is no better example than you; you who have found a true purpose or meaning to life. You have engaged , and continue to do so, in service to humanity for decades and we all salute you,

      Delete
    2. Lama
      Your list of achievements and activities after retirement is truly impressive.I salute you.
      You are indeed blessed to have been able to continue Teaching and Adminstrative activities and of course Clinical practice which you enjoy .

      Most of us are not so fortunate. We are forced to restrict our clinical activities to Private practice. It's so different from working in a state hospital
      where you are challenged and have the satisfaction of serving our Motherland.
      Private patients also have a different attitude to us

      So we have to find alternative ways of keeping occupied and feeling useful. I found engaging in Social Service immensely rewarding
      I have been visiting
      " Methsevana a Rehabilitation centre for women prisoners weekly for about 6 years.Believe me it's an eye opener ! Had to give it up during the COVID pandemic.Each of us have to find our solution to battle against boredom !

      Delete
  8. Above comment is from Suri

    ReplyDelete
  9. Mahen and everyone else, all of you are "living well" and doing everything you can to live life joyfully, as well as contribute to society in multiple ways. Although I don't practice medicine any more, I have also found ways to continue living a meaningful life. But, there is something else that needs our attention. Mahen said in his article "Death is as inevitable as life and without death, life cannot be sustained. Death is not a failure; accept death with dignity and equanimity." How many of us have had a conversation with our children and spouses about our wishes for our final exit. (I'm writing this but I haven't yet had a serious conversation with my daughters, although they are aware of some of my wishes). If we develop an illness where recovery is unlikely, do we wish to be kept alive and fed with gastric tubes etc? It is difficult to cover all scenarios, but we need to think about these possibilities and convey our wishes to our loved ones.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Srianee has prompted us on another important aspect, palliative care and assisted dying, The UK House of commons has submitted its second report which is available for public access through the web. It posed a few extremey relevant set of questions for which they asked for responses. Before I go into my own appreciation of the issues that we have to deal with, I thought these questions they posed would interest you.
    "We asked for submissions to focus on the following terms of reference:"

    To what extent do people in England and Wales have access to good palliative care?
    How can palliative care be improved, and would such improvements negate some of the arguments for assisted dying/assisted suicide?
    What can be learnt from the evidence in countries where assisted dying/assisted suicide is legal?
    What are the professional and ethical considerations involved in allowing physicians to assist someone to end their life?
    What, if any, are the physical and mental health criteria which would make an individual eligible to access assisted dying/assisted suicide services?
    What protections could be put in place to protect people from coercion and how effective would these be?
    What information, advice and guidance would people need in order to be able to make an informed decision about whether to access assisted dying/assisted suicide services?
    What capabilities would a person need to be able to consent to assisted dying/assisted suicide?
    What should the Government’s role be in relation to the debate?

    ReplyDelete
  11. A few years ago when I was in Sri Lanka I explored the availability of hospice and palliative on behalf of a sick friend. There was a hospice facility near the Maharagama Cancer Hospital, but that was it! I think it was restricted to patients with terminal cancer. The concept of palliative care was non-existent.
    I did a search a few days ago and I was pleased to learn that the Sri Lanka Medical Association now has a task force. It appears that discussions are ongoing. I found a few links for interested folks. This is definitely a step in the right direction. I think physician assisted death is highly unlikely in Sri Lanka in our lifetime. Every situation is different, and there could be many possible scenarios in our future. We need to have those uncomfortable discussions with our families, and convey our wishes to our nearest and dearest, so that they won't have to guess when they are faced with decisions.
    Some useful information:
    ehospice.com/asia-pacific-posts
    https://www.slma.lk/palliative care task force
    https://www.nccp.health.gov.lk

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thank you very much Mahendra and Srianee for bringing up this important topic of Palliative Care for discussion. More and more local physicians are getting interested in this neglected, but very important area. There are a few publications as well; the PGIM is also focusing on it

    ReplyDelete
  13. As I was never involved in direct patient care I needed a definition of palliative care. This is what I found which shows undoubtedly its importance in every caring society and every country.
    Palliative care is specialized medical care for people living with a serious illness. This type of care is focused on providing relief from the symptoms and stress of the illness. The goal is to improve quality of life for both the patient and the family.

    Palliative care is provided by a specially-trained team of doctors, nurses and other specialists who work together with a patient’s other doctors to provide an extra layer of support. Palliative care is based on the needs of the patient, not on the patient’s prognosis. It is appropriate at any age and at any stage in a serious illness, and it can be provided along with curative treatment.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Sorry, I have missed out a bit in this sentence -"Terminal care applies to a whole range of illnesses characterised by a period of steady deteriotration with no cure" . Please add "and refers to the final relatively short phase of Palliative care ending in death"

    ReplyDelete