Sunday, April 28, 2024

LIVING....AND DYING. Mahendra Gonsalkorale

LIVING....AND DYING 

Mahendra "Speedy" Gonsalkorale

Yet another member of our batch has passed away, and The Blog is in its last throes -
It is sometimes helpful to think about the unthinkable

This has put me in a reflective mood, and I would like to share my thoughts with my colleagues. Although this may sound doleful at first, it is meant to be celebratory of the lives we have led and a recognition that we must value the past and make the best use of the time left for us.

Life is possible only because it is inexorably linked with death. Although we recognised death from a very early stage in our lives, it was something that was there in the background, and we didn’t pay much attention to it and indeed tended to avoid thinking about it as it was not pleasant to be reminded that you and your loved ones are transient. I use the word transient in a relative sense. What is transient is a matter of perception. Your life is transient compared to the life of the Universe! and almost eternal compared to that of a dragonfly.

I am of the opinion that although there are many reasons for the arising of religion, one powerful stimulus was the desire to “extend” your life. Some sort of afterlife is part of all religious beliefs. It provides some comfort and a basis for moral laws. We all like to see “good” being rewarded and “bad” being punished. When examining this, Man inevitably sees something extraordinary beyond his capacity to understand how this operates. He sees a possible mechanism for this to operate through a God or Gods or some “spiritual law”. This causes problems such as why so much hardship and sadness exists in the presence of a God who is apparently either choosy, hasn’t got the power, or is non-existent. Any doubt about the power He is alleged to have is overcome by a belief or faith that, although it appears so, we cannot appreciate the true nature of the grand design. What we see as His failure is in fact our failure.

Man requires some sort of “immediate” reassurance when in difficulty. The Buddhist concept of Nirvana is too distant and is of little help in these situations, hence the intermingling of mainly Hindu concepts, such as worshipping deities and inanimate objects, such as statutes, throughout the cultural history of Buddhism. They can postpone the attainment of Nirvana for a future birth but do enough good now to keep their merit score high enough not to stray from the path.

What am I leading to? Firstly, to accept that death is real and without it, paradoxically, life is not possible. Secondly, we cannot take our material possessions with us at the journey's end. Thirdly, if human beings have the capacity to determine what the absolute “truth” is, they have not yet done so. If they had done so conclusively, there would be only one Religion. I think we must recognise the importance of faith (saddha), reverence and the comfort it provides to many. We can debate and form our conclusions on an intellectual dimension, but this is separate from aspects of human need.

The final question is whether we have the capacity to understand reality by mere intuition or through rational sifting of evidence through learning. The Buddhist philosophy implies that intuition is possible.

This leads me to believe we should be humble, understand the needs of others, be empathetic, be nonjudgmental, and think beyond the material universe. Death reminds us of our common destiny, the need to live in the present, and the need to cultivate our minds more than our physical aspects.

5 comments:

  1. Mahendra
    Well done. What a thought provoking article !
    I agree with you that we must value the past and make the best use of the time left for us. I think we should look back and enjoy the happy moments we have had with our families, friends, batchmates etc.
    As you said life is transient, so let us enjoy life this short period left in our lives
    Death is real. Life after death is according to our religious beliefs.
    We have all come to the end of our lives. I think we should occupy our time with some sort of activity, exercise, playing tennis, badminton, golf, painting, sewing etc.
    We don't know what we are in for the future. Till such time let us be happy and enjoy life by meeting families, relatives, friends, batchmates etc.
    Chira

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks, Chira. It is wotrthwhile thinking about these things at our stage in life. I am glad you found it useful

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mahen
    Thank you for your thoughts that are most appropriate and timely as we say goodbye to people who have grown up with us. We lead finite lives. I firmly believe we live and we die and thats the end of the story. This is not a subject I wish to dwell on for long at this stage of my life.
    Religion may mean many things to many people. To me it was to teach me to live a good life and it did although I may not have kept to those teachings always.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nihal and Chira, to appreciate others viewpoints is so important. Not only must we understand ourselves but we must extend this to others and by going so it helps to lead a more contender life

    ReplyDelete
  5. Mahen, thank you for posting a very thought provoking article. From the lack of participation I get the feeling that many of us would rather not think about the inevitable! My delay in participating is because I was re-entering the American airspace and was bogged down with silly little time consuming details. I felt that I had landed on a different planet!
    I feel that we all need to prepare ourselves and our loved ones for our inevitable exit, but continue to enjoy life. I really liked your last paragraph:
    "This leads me to believe we should be humble, understand the needs of others, be empathetic, be nonjudgmental, and think beyond the material universe. Death reminds us of our common destiny, the need to live in the present, and the need to cultivate our minds more than our physical aspects."
    I feel that most of us need religion to guide us to live a good life. We 'believe' but do we 'know' for sure? Not really. Religious beliefs also help to build communities of like minded people. But, when religious beliefs become fanatical, divisive, and lead to intolerance and violence, is it any wonder that intelligent people eschew religion?

    ReplyDelete